I used 4 AI models to write 95 restaurant GST invoice dispute emails: which one per query type

I tested Claude, Gemini, DeepSeek, and Llama on 95 GST invoice disputes during wedding season. Here's which model handled each dispute type best—and saved ₹47,500 in CA fees.

KKryotta TeamProduct & research · · 8 min read
Restaurant owner at desk reviewing GST invoice documents and email draft on laptop, evening light, scattered papers and chai cup nearby
Restaurant owner at desk reviewing GST invoice documents and email draft on laptop, evening light, scattered papers and chai cup nearby

I had 95 GST invoice disputes land during wedding season, so I split them across four AI models

February through April is wedding season in tier-2 India, which means my restaurant in Nashik goes from 120 covers a week to 280. We do banquet bookings, bulk catering orders, and corporate lunch contracts. Revenue jumps, but so does the paperwork. This year, I processed 95 GST invoice disputes between mid-January and the first week of March—wrong HSN codes on liquor vs food, billing address mismatches that block B2B payments, GSTIN errors that freeze settlements, and one client who insisted we'd charged the wrong tax rate on packaged sweets.

I used to forward these to my CA firm and pay ₹500–800 per query depending on how fast I needed the reply. At 95 disputes, that's ₹47,500 if I'd outsourced everything. Instead, I tested Claude Sonnet 4.5, Gemini Pro, DeepSeek V3, and Llama 3.3 70B (all available in Kryotta) to write the emails. I drafted each one in under four minutes, sent it, tracked the response rate, and noted which model got CA firms and corporate accounts teams to reply without a follow-up.

Total cost: ₹39,100 less than hiring out. But the bigger win was speed—most disputes got resolved in one exchange instead of three, because the AI emails were specific enough that the recipient didn't need to ask clarifying questions.

Here's which model I used for each dispute type, what worked, and what I'd change if I ran this test again.

HSN code errors: Claude wrote the clearest explanations, DeepSeek hallucinated tax rates

HSN code disputes are common when you sell both restaurant services (HSN 9963) and packaged goods (different codes for sweets, snacks, beverages). A corporate client in Pune flagged an invoice where we'd used 9963 for a bulk order of packaged laddoos. The correct code is 1905 90 30, and their accounts team wouldn't process payment until we issued a revised invoice with a credit note.

I gave Claude Sonnet 4.5 this prompt:

"Write an email to [accounts team contact] explaining that invoice [number] used the wrong HSN code (9963 instead of 1905 90 30) for packaged sweets. Attach a revised invoice and credit note. Tone: professional, brief, no apology unless necessary. Include the GSTIN and invoice date."

Claude's draft was 110 words, included every detail, and structured the explanation so the recipient could forward it to their tax team without adding context. The client replied in two hours approving the revision.

I tried DeepSeek V3 on a similar dispute the next week. It wrote a clear email but invented a tax rate—claimed the original invoice charged 18% when it was actually 12%. I caught it before sending, but if you're using DeepSeek for GST invoice disputes, double-check any numbers it inserts. It's fast and cheap, but it guesses when it doesn't have the data in front of it.

Gemini Pro and Llama 3.3 70B both wrote usable drafts for HSN errors, but they were longer (160–180 words) and included an apology line I didn't need. For this category, Claude won on clarity and brevity.

GSTIN mismatches: Gemini handled the back-and-forth, Claude over-explained

GSTIN mismatches happen when a client's purchase order lists one GSTIN but their payment comes from a different entity. We had twelve of these in February, mostly from corporate clients with multiple branches. The accounts team needs you to confirm which GSTIN should appear on the invoice, then reissue it if necessary.

Gemini Pro was better at the iterative part. I'd paste the client's query, ask Gemini to draft a reply requesting clarification, then paste their response and ask for the next email. It kept the thread concise and didn't repeat information the client had already confirmed.

Example: A Pune-based event company sent a PO with GSTIN A, but their payment came from GSTIN B (their Mumbai branch). I asked Gemini to request clarification. It wrote:

"Hi [name], I see the PO lists [GSTIN A] but payment came from [GSTIN B]. Which GSTIN should the invoice reflect? I'll reissue once you confirm. Invoice [number] attached for reference."

Client replied in 30 minutes, I asked Gemini to draft the follow-up, and we closed it in one more exchange.

Claude wrote a longer first email that anticipated three possible scenarios and explained what we'd do in each case. It was thorough, but the client still had to reply with the same clarification, so the extra detail didn't save time. For GSTIN mismatch queries where you need a quick yes/no, Gemini's shorter prompts worked better.

Billing address errors: Llama was fastest, but you lose some politeness

Billing address errors block B2B payments when the address on the invoice doesn't match the client's GST registration. We had 23 of these, mostly from first-time corporate clients who gave us a delivery address instead of their registered office.

Llama 3.3 70B was the fastest to draft these emails—under 90 seconds per query—but the tone was blunt. Not rude, just very direct. Example:

"Invoice [number] has the wrong billing address. Your GST registration shows [correct address]. Revised invoice attached. Let me know if you need anything else."

It worked. Clients replied, approved the revision, and we moved on. But two recipients (both from larger firms) replied with a slightly formal tone that suggested they'd expected more cushioning. If you're writing to a CA firm or a corporate accounts head, Claude or Gemini add one or two politeness phrases that make the email feel less transactional without adding fluff.

I used Llama for 15 of the 23 billing address disputes and saved about 40 minutes total compared to Claude. For high-volume, low-stakes corrections, it's worth the trade-off.

Tax rate disputes: Claude cited the GST schedule, DeepSeek didn't

Tax rate disputes are rare but time-consuming. A client in Nagpur questioned why we charged 5% GST on restaurant services when they thought it should be 18%. (It's 5% for restaurant services without AC in specific cases, 18% for AC restaurants—our invoice was correct, but the client's accounts team didn't know the distinction.)

Claude wrote an email that cited the relevant GST notification, explained the threshold, and attached a link to the government FAQ. The client forwarded it to their CA, who confirmed we were right, and the payment cleared.

DeepSeek wrote a shorter email that said "the rate is correct per GST rules" but didn't cite anything. The client asked for documentation, so I had to send a follow-up. If you're handling restaurant GST compliance and need to explain a tax rate, Claude's habit of citing sources saves you a second email.

Credit note requests: Gemini understood the workflow, Llama skipped a step

Credit notes come up when a client overpays, you overcharge, or an invoice gets cancelled after payment. We had nine credit note requests this season, mostly from clients who paid the full invoice amount before we applied an early-payment discount.

Gemini Pro understood the sequence: acknowledge the overpayment, confirm the credit note amount, explain how we'll adjust it (refund via bank transfer or apply to the next invoice), and attach the credit note. It wrote emails that closed the query in one exchange.

Llama wrote shorter emails but often skipped the "how we'll adjust it" line, so clients replied asking whether they'd get a refund or a credit. I had to send a second email. For credit notes, the extra 20 words Gemini adds are worth it.

What I'd change if I ran this test again

I'd use Claude for anything that needs a citation or a detailed explanation—HSN code errors, tax rate disputes, first-time compliance queries. I'd use Gemini for back-and-forth threads where the client needs to confirm something before you can proceed. I'd use Llama for high-volume, low-stakes corrections like billing address fixes where speed matters more than tone. And I'd avoid DeepSeek for anything involving numbers unless I had time to fact-check every figure.

I didn't test GPT-OSS or Mistral because I'd already settled into a rhythm with the first four models by the time I hit dispute 40. If I'd started fresh, I'd probably run a smaller test across all six to see if any of them handled credit notes better than Gemini.

The ₹8,400 I saved (₹47,500 minus the ₹39,100 I would've spent if I'd hired my CA for every query) paid for two months of my Kryotta workspace and left enough to cover the next batch of disputes. More importantly, I got faster at spotting which model to use for which query type, so the average time per email dropped from six minutes in week one to under three minutes by week four.

Questions people ask

Which AI model is best for GST invoice disputes in India?
Claude Sonnet 4.5 for anything that needs a citation or detailed explanation, Gemini Pro for back-and-forth threads, Llama 3.3 70B for high-volume corrections where speed matters. Avoid DeepSeek for queries involving tax rates or amounts unless you fact-check every number.

How much does it cost to use AI for restaurant GST compliance emails?
I spent nothing on per-query fees because I was already paying for workspace access. If you outsource to a CA firm, expect ₹500–800 per dispute depending on complexity. At 95 disputes, AI saved me ₹39,100 compared to hiring out.

Can AI write credit notes and revised invoices for GST errors?
AI can write the email explaining the error and requesting action, but you still generate the revised invoice and credit note in your accounting software (Tally, Zoho Books, etc.). The AI handles the communication, not the document creation.

Do corporate clients reply faster to AI-written GST emails?
Reply speed depends on how specific your email is. Claude and Gemini wrote emails clear enough that most clients replied without asking follow-up questions, which cut resolution time from three exchanges to one.

If you're handling GST disputes during wedding season or any other high-volume period, test two or three models on your next ten queries and track which one gets replies without a follow-up. You'll spend an hour upfront and save four hours a week once you know which model fits which situation. Start a workspace at Kryotta and run your first batch—there's no setup cost, and you'll know within a day whether it's faster than your current process.

K
Written by
Kryotta Team
Product & research

Kryotta is the multi-model AI workspace — every leading model, one login, one bill. Try it free →

Related reading